The Beauty of Architecture without Aesthetics: Dignifying the Marginalized.
We architects have our own aesthetic sensibilities because of which we often disregard those beyond our set standards. The slums and shanties that we perceive as dirty patches to our cities have a beauty of their own, the beauty of struggle, survival and spirit.
“For three years, that used to be my bedroom and this was the kitchen, we had five toilets and our shop was on the street,” says Meena, one of the 120,000 victims of Yamuna Pushta slums demolition in 2004. The bedroom she pointed at was a parking lot where cars were being replaced by unkempt jute sacks, the kitchen was a dingy pavement where a woman in a rugged saree was cooking and the toilet was a clogged public one. Her shop was the traffic light where she ran barefoot on the burning tar, selling newspapers. This has been the plight of about 150,000 Meenas for the past decade in Delhi. Winning the bid in the year 2003 for the Common Wealth Games (CWG)-2010, exacerbated the situation of homelessness in Delhi. This large-scale sports event, improved investments, boosted tourism and strengthened the infrastructure, but it also scarred the city with negative social legacies. These ranged from the loss of livelihoods to the loss of life savings invested in small businesses and in building shanties, making the most marginalized population even more vulnerable, and amounting to human rights violation. While large-scale financial irregularities in the games were given considerable attention, the human and social impact was largely ignored.
Delhi being the national capital offers the best medical and infrastructural amenities and economic opportunities, which attract migrants to the city. After 2003, thousands were rendered homeless for city beautification, construction of sports venues and widening of roads. Additionally, rapid construction for the games kept attracting more workers. This hard-working population toiled day and night to build/clean/run the city and was rewarded with joblessness and homelessness after the event ended. “We will have about three lakh (300,000) homeless in the city after the games. Housing for them will be a priority after the Games” said the Chief Minister of Delhi.
The sinusoidal curve of social justice had reached its absolute bottom and so, restitution was inevitable. In January 2010, Delhi High Court Chief Justice AP Shah initiated a suo moto case against the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) for demolishing a homeless shelter on Pusa Roundabout and leaving 250 homeless out on the streets. He ordered them to rebuild the shelter and to not evict homeless on humanitarian grounds. This led to the formation of Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board (DUSIB) with the objective to construct and finance homeless shelters. During our study for writing the essay, we found out about this social calamity. Being accustomed to such scenarios, we never perceived it as such a huge problem, even though one of us interned in the city for last six months and the other was born and brought up in the city. Is this just an exaggeration or the reality?
The question kept haunting us until we, with our new found insight, went back and explored the city again, and to our surprise, this time, we could locate not only a lot of homeless but a lot of shelters too. The cluster of shelters located in Dandi Park, managed by an NGO “Prayas”, caught our attention. Amidst the chaotic jungle of concrete, it was an oasis of serenity. The cool colors of blue shelters, green trees, and brownish paving tiles gave it a scenic beauty. Open planning was adapted by clustering five portable shelters around a central court. One of the shelters was for women and children, one for elderly and the disabled and three for single men, sheltering about 950 people. At the entrance, we met Hari Prasad, a rickshaw puller who was parking his rickshaw. “For the security of my rickshaw, I used to curl up in the three feet long and one feet wide seat at night,” he said, “this is the only shelter which provides space and security for my rickshaw”. Ram Shankar, a cobbler while putting his blankets in the locker and hanging his toolset on his back, said, “We have got guards now when even some of the colonies don’t have one”.
It was here that we met Meena who was kind enough to offer us drinking water from the earthen pots kept inside the shelters. She was a house helper in the neighboring houses. Her husband and son lived in the shelter for men. “We are saving money to rent a home so we can live together. Life here has been good, at least, my son will not have the same destiny as mine” said she. “Hope” seemed to be returning to her voice. Though the purpose of the shelter was providing mere roofing, its location facilitated employment too. The place might not have had tiled floors, carved doors, high ceilings or any other physical ornamentation but its beauty could be felt in the transformation it brought in these lives.
Despite the heat outside, when we entered the cabin, we felt a sudden relief, the air cavities in the PVC sheets and the shade from surrounding trees ensured a comfortable temperature inside. Few aspects facilitated the people to adapt and personalize the built and the unbuilt, enabling a sense of community. The entrance had an interesting temple-like formation evolved from a rural setting, with photographs of Hindu goddesses in a hollow tree trunk. Platforms around the trees resembled and were used as Chaupals [traditional gathering spaces]. An apt blend of built and unbuilt was present as the existing trees were respected while installing the shelters. Bio-toilets dignified the inhabitants. The facilities were provided at a nominal charge of Rs. 10 ($ 0.17) from which the elderly and differently abled were exempted.
The fee gives the motive to earn, the sense of entitlement, the power to ask questions, the right to demand rather than beg, and most importantly, the realization that being sheltered is their right and not somebody’s pittance.
In addition to shelters, “Prayas” facilitates counseling, relocation, health care and de-addiction facilities as most of the homeless slave to alcoholism and drug addictions and suffer from depression. The caretakers, cleaners, guards and even volunteers, working with “Prayas”, are people who themselves have been through the agonizing voyage of vagabondage. “I have seen those days, madam, felt those demeaning stares. Helping them helps me repay the kindness which I received” said Dinesh, a security guard in the shelter. They offer support rather than an empty pittance and are role models for the ones who want to escape their affliction.
Prayas, literal meaning “endeavor”, was founded by Mr. Amod Kanth in 1988 as a Juvenile Aid Society. When asked about his journey from being the Director General of Police to establishing the NGO, he recalled his first effort to house about 20 children orphaned in a fire. After this, other officers joined him in an effort to help more and more people. They became a registered organization working with the most deprived. Currently, the organization manages 30 shelters housing about 4,000 people.
The homeless have no address in the city, which deprives them of access to even the most basic urban services. Having an address is the most important factor in giving a citizen an identity and legitimate rights. “I think nothing is done for us because we aren’t a vote bank,” said Ram Prasad, standing in a queue to deposit his weekly savings in the Mobile Banking Van. “Prayas” issues identity cards which help the homeless in opening bank accounts, which in turn help them in registering for getting ration cards and voter IDs. Being able to exercise their right to vote makes them important to elected city councilors. Every day we meet individuals who are either homeless or on the verge of becoming one. Being better informed now, has transformed the way we look at them. “We are the rag pickers, rickshaw pullers, workers, we run the city, we ease their life,” said Poonam, the street hawker, “they think of us as criminals.” Spreading awareness and understanding that it is the disgust, apathy and loneliness that develops the psyche of homelessness can help in curbing the prejudices. Working and volunteering at the local level can dilute this stigma. Doctors conducting free check-ups; lawyers getting justice to poor; teachers educating them, in fact, any person with any special talent, providing them vocational training to make them self-sufficient can change another human’s life.
Desmond Tutu puts it in correct words “My humanity is bound up in yours, for we can only be human together”.
There are many instances where families who have been given apartments by the government have moved back to the streets. This is because many are entrepreneurs with occupations which they operate from their homes, like rag pickers. “We cannot carry our wares to the 4th storey of these buildings every night,” said Poonam. This shows that we architects and authorities are clueless about their needs. We as architects need to stick to the basic approaches to designing, the first being user study. “We don’t really like being here, this seems like a railway platform,” said Shankar a resident of the shelter in Yamuna Pushta talking about the pre-fabricated shelter. Understanding the many points of view of homeless individuals regarding shelter, safety and use of built space are imperative. And here the second step, “participatory approach” can be brought in. “These men, you architects disregard as illiterate fools, have been surviving in the city for years, they know how to build with whatever is available,” says Vishwajeet Ghoshal, a member of team “Prayas”. Involving them in designing and construction can increase their emotional attachment with the shelters and also provide them with some money and skills. And, here the third step, use of locally available resources, comes in. In addition, to the local materials and technologies, the knowledge of these people is also a locally available resource which needs to be used.
Having a better understanding of built spaces, we as architects can locate hidden niches woven into the urban fabric and use them judiciously. “Construction work is very tiring. All I need at the end of the day is an uninterrupted sleep” said Ramesh, a construction worker who sleeps on the footpath, where we found him. A Spatio-temporal approach towards the use of buildings can be a way of providing shelter at night by using existing infrastructures like schools, offices, underpasses etc. Also, night shelters can themselves be designed in such a way that they can be used for social purposes such as centers for health care, training and adult education, during the day. As architects, we have a say in the design program of buildings. While designing any public institution, innovative approaches to serve the most marginalized can be applied. For instance, all public hospitals can be designed with shelters to house families of poor resident patients. In places lacking the facility, the current model currently in practice in Delhi of using discarded buses as shelters to serve the floating population.
Learnings from our case study of “Dandi Park” should be incorporated while designing new shelters. Instead of making isolated shelters, clusters should be made. These clusters inhabiting different social groups create inclusion and also a gender-sensitive environment. Services can be provided together makes it cost effective and the transitional spaces can be used for training, teaching or gathering. Integration of biophilic design to use the restorative and healing effects of nature should be done too.
In a situation where the homeless lack the basics of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs i.e. food, water and sleep, providing basic services becomes first priority. We can, at least, make their days less tedious. They may not have a stake in the decision-making for public spaces, but they are its primary users. Spatial allocation like benches to sleep on, more public restrooms and at the very least, not designing anti-homeless features in public places, can create an inclusive society. Principles of “Crime Prevention through Environmental Design” should be applied not against the homeless, but for them, as it is they who are most vulnerable to theft, harassment and violence. It is possible that once the basics have been met, many may be able to rise above their present condition to meet the second level in Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. These ideas can be a quick fix and may end up saving lives in the extremities of Delhi’s climate. But living is much beyond existence, a person living in a shelter is still homeless. Bringing people back in the community and improving long-term prospects need concrete solutions, literally.
Cities like Utah and Vancouver have mitigated their problems of chronic homelessness by providing permanent homes. But in these cities, the homeless population was much lesser than Delhi’s. A shelter is only the first point of intervention and cannot replace the basic right to housing for all. In Delhi, the sheer magnitude of the population in need of houses makes the idea of the government building housing for all, a preposterous one. Additionally, being the second most populated and twelfth most dense city, Delhi has an acute shortage of land. Delhi should facilitate these people to build their own homes in a better way.
The lessons from the whole experience is, first the physical attributes: location respecting the employment and population density, flexibility in use, safety and services, biophilic design, inclusiveness and second the environmental attributes: healthfulness, scope of personalization, sense of belongingness and community, incorporation of native lifestyle and respect and dignity, can define the success and failure of a design. We also learned that providing them housing without inviting them to play a role in building, rips them of their dignity and is not effective in a long run.
Homelessness can be mitigated only by sensible design ideologies that “equip” them to contribute to and give back to the society. Only then, will they truly be accepted and included in the society. “Teach him how to fish, and he will eat forever” goes the proverb.
What we understood was that CWG-2010 might have aggravated the issue of homelessness, but even before this event, the problem was visibly present but ignored. The games drew people’s attention to it and forced the authorities to act. Post games, Delhi has seen large budget allocations for building shelters, a tremendous rise in the number of shelters and NGOs and even apps for the public to report the position of homeless to be sheltered. You can still easily locate this population but what has changed is that you can also locate shelters. The solutions might not be very pleasing to your eyes but there is an aesthetic quality to them beyond what mere eyes can see.
To conclude, we would like to add that in an era where the distance between two continents is just a matter of hours, the distance from pavements to homes should not take generations.
[ This essay by Jyoti Kiran and Durga Prasad Gupta of School of Planning and Architecture, Bhopal, was one of the 16 shortlisted entries of the Berkeley Essay Competition 2016 that invites social proposals from all over the world.
Each year the PRIZE Committee selects a topic important to the understanding of the interaction of people and the built world that becomes the focus of the Essay Competition to promote the investigation of architecture as a social art. This year the topic was: Sheltering Those in Need: Architects Confront Homelessness. ]
Video Posted on
Last Sunday saw MG Road in Bangalore transform from a noisy thoroughfare to a lively, bustling public space, free from cars and traffic. ‘Open Streets’ , orgranised by Department of Urban Land Transport (DULT) and Bangalore coalition for Open Streets, was a landmark event in Bangalore’s struggle for pedestrian friendly streets. Parking lots were replaced by nearly 120 stalls, flea markets, art installations, and dance performances, attracting more than 50000 people in the course of the day.
From 9am to 9pm, MG Road was jam packed with people strolling, children playing badminton and speed ball, college students painting and singing, with the atmosphere of a carnival. Fun and frolic aside, this event drove home the invaluable importance of pedestrian spaces on streets, popularized public transport and called out to the people to reclaim the streets as their own!
Here’s a time-lapse video which captures the spirit and gaiety of the event that brought together people of all ages, cultures and even nationalities. And here’s to more such events on busy roads that ought to be reclaimed by the people. Share to show your support for Open Streets in your city!
[Video shot and edited by Siddarth PT]
Are you one of those people who love looking down from air planes at the world, as it shrinks? Or do you spend hours zooming in and out of maps, gazing at the patterns and forms? Did you love the movie UP for daring to fly ‘up above the world so high’? Are you someone who simply gets the thrill of discovering an amazing view? Then read on.
Humans have always been fascinated with the view from up above, something that was out of reach till the advent of Google Maps and Google Earth, one of the greatest achievements of mankind. (How it has changed the world is a fascinating story by itself. More on that later). Coming to the point, this was the idea behind Daily Overview, an Instagram account created by Benjamin Grant, inspired by the Overview Effect. The Overview Effect is the cognitive shift in awareness, the feeling you get while viewing the Earth from above- a feeling of awe, a profound, deep understanding of life and existence, and most importantly, a renewed sense of responsibility towards the planet.
Everyday the Daily Overview posts high resolution images of the Earth from above, that highlight the effect of man’s activities on Earth. Devastatingly beautiful, their images cannot fail to evoke a sense of disbelief that these places actually exist.
To put it in their own words, “From our line of sight on the earth’s surface, it’s impossible to fully appreciate the beauty and intricacy of the things we’ve constructed, the sheer complexity of the systems we’ve developed, or the devastating impact that we’ve had on our planet. The Overviews focus on the places and moments where human activity—for better or for worse—has shaped the landscape. Each Overview starts with a thought experiment.”
Now, these posts have the potential to teach us a lot about cities and look at it in a new light; some distance is all that one needs to gain some perspective on things. Every image is accompanied by a thought provoking caption on context the human impact over the landscape. The flatness of the image seen from this vantage point is almost graphic with the vibrant colours and throws us off with the massive scale. Here are few of the most interesting Overviews of cities and city life.
Rocinha, built upon a steep hillside overlooking Rio de Janeiro, is the largest favela in Brazil. Covering only .8 square miles, the population of the urbanized slum is estimated somewhere between 70,000 and 200,000. Residents occupy shanties made of concrete and brick that are stacked on top of each other, with some climbing as high as 11 stories.
To celebrate our 175K follower milestone, we’re doing a PRINT GIVEAWAY from our Printshop!!! To enter the contest, simply TAG FOUR (4) FRIENDS in the comments of this Overview. In 72 hours, we’ll announce a winner who will receive a print with this amazing view of Central Park in New York City. Located in the middle of Manhattan, the park spans 843 acres, or 6% of the borough. Thank you all for your support and best of luck with the contest!
The glowing lights of Las Vegas, Nevada are captured here from the International Space Station. Since the city is entirely surrounded by desert, its brightly lit grid of streets starkly contrasts the dark, undeveloped area on its outskirts. You’ll also notice the Las Vegas Strip – the city’s central avenue that is seen at the middle of this Overview. This particular area is one of the brightest spots on Earth due to the concentration of lights emanating from the hotels and casinos along the road. Source imagery: @nasa
Colorful, metal-roofed industrial buildings line the coast of Tokai, Japan. The city’s economy is dominated by a massive steel mill – a portion of which is seen at the bottom of this Overview. Nippon Steel, the company that owns the mill, has an annual production of more than 47 million tons of steel across its various facilities. Steels – consisting of alloys of iron and other elements, primarily carbon – is a major component in buildings, infrastructure, tools, ships, automobiles, appliances, and weapons.
Valparaíso, Chile is built upon dozens of steep hillsides overlooking the Pacific Ocean. Known as “The Jewel of the Pacific,” the city is the sixth largest in the country and is home to approximately 285,000 residents. Valparaíso is also home to the country’s first public library, South America’s first volunteer fire department, and the world’s longest running Spanish language newspaper in continuous publication.
Today is Martin Luther King, Jr. Day here in the United States – honoring the Baptist minister, activist, humanitarian, and leader of the African-American Civil Rights Movement. This overview captures the Lincoln Memorial during King’s famous “I Have A Dream Speech” in Washington, D.C. on August 28, 1963. In front of more than 250,000 civil rights supporters, King described his dreams of freedom and equality arising from a land of slavery and hatred.
Albenga is a city situated on the Gulf of Genoa in Italy. The economy of Albenga is primarily driven by tourism, local commerce, and agriculture. When viewing the town from above, it’s easy to see the amount of space dedicated to agriculture because of the widespread use of greenhouses or “plasticulture." The use of plastic covering is designed to increase produce yield, increase produce size, and shorten growth time.
New Delhi serves as the capital of India and is home to more than 21 million residents in its metro area. Officially inaugurated in February 1931, the city was planned by British architects Sir Edwin Lutyens and Sir Herbert Baker. Their design centered around two promenades – the Rajpath and Janpath – that run perpendicular to each other and intersect here at center. For a sense of scale, this Overview shows approximately four square miles.
Chimalhuacán is a city with more than 600,000 residents in the eastern part of the State of Mexico, Mexico. The colorful strip seen across the bottom of this Overview is a open-air market known as a tianguis. Here, merchants cover their stalls with vibrant canopies to protect themselves from harsh sun and inclement weather.
Houses swirl on the hills of Umlazi – a township in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. The present site of Umlazi was occupied by American missionaries in 1836 and only opened to black residents in 1965, many of whom moved there from Durban. The current population of the township is approximately 405,000.
Video Posted on Updated on
I came across this video last year, while I was doing my dissertation on “Causal Nexus of Globalization in Architecture”. Globalization, in general terms, is the process of international integration arising from the interchange of world views, ideas and other aspects of culture. The process of connecting different parts of the world to one another began 70,000 years ago when Homo sapiens, gifted with an intellect that allowed for adaptation to an alien environment, walked out of Africa. Over time, we’ve created and destroyed many cities, and cities themselves became the epitome of human achievement. Yet now, we are at a time where cities are losing their charm and essence due to unorganized growth and rapid development to meet the ever growing demand.
This Video by “School of Life” is a manifesto of six key principles behind the design of cities which are interestingly described with examples from all around the world and eye catching illustrations. “We’ve grown good at making many things in the modern world – but strangely the art of making cities has been lost” is the premise behind the video and the six principles are:
- Not too Chaotic, Not too Orderly
- Visible Life
- Orientation and Mystery
- Making it Local
The video ends by questioning the idea of beauty itself, do we have the right to say what’s beautiful and what’s not beautiful? – “The intellectual confusions around Beauty.”
Would you like to know exactly what your ecological footprint is, and why it is what it is because you live in a city? Are you a person who drives to work everyday or do you use public transport? Do u live in the suburbs or do u live in the centre of the city? Mostly importantly, how does urban design affect a city’s ecological footprint?
Global Footprints Network is an organization that asked all these questions and came up with a method to answer them in a calculative manner. Ecological Footprint — a resource accounting tool that measures how much nature we have, how much we use, and who uses what. This method, overlaid with existing patterns of consumption and living in cities is used to calculate the Ecological Footprint of a city/country. Check out global statistics for Footprint per capita in this interactive map. Split into five categories, this shows where each country stands with respect to global standards. FYI, looking at India’s situation, we can start panicking now.
It is a known fact that cities and the ecologically destructive, urban way of living place a huge strain on global resources. “The global effort for sustainability will be won, or lost, in the world’s cities, where urban design may influence over 70 percent of people’s Ecological Footprint and 80 percent of the world’s population is expected to live by 2050.” High footprint cities in the world consume five-ten times more than the global average, but this strain can be greatly reduced through sensible urban design.
“Since urban infrastructure is long-lasting and influences resource needs for decades to come, infrastructure decisions make or break a city’s future. Which ones are building opportunities for resource-efficient and more competitive lifestyles? Which cities are building future resource traps?”
A well designed public transit system in a city can save thousands of kilometers of private-travel-trips around the city. Well designed pavements and sidewalks may make the difference between choosing to walk to the neighborhood tea-shop and taking the scooter or car. An infrastructure development like the Metro Rail in Chennai now, can affect the trajectory of growth in the future.
And how do we as urban dwellers contribute to the ecological footprint of our city? How do our lifestyle choices make a difference? What can we do to change our city’s ecological footprint? Again, GFN has an answer, a way to find that out and see where we stand globally, as individuals. Measure your urban lifestyle here. See where you stand and let us know in the comments!
So, this semester in college, we did an interesting study on Placemaking and Public Spaces, as part of our design of a Civic Centre in Kanchipuram, a temple town in South India. And the highlight of that particular study was this TED Talk by Amanda Burden, New York’s Chief city planner. She begins by emphasizing how a city is fundamentally about its people and goes on to state examples from all over New York, where good Urban Design essentially meant a design by and for the people. The transformation of the Highline and HydePark in New York is beautifully captured in her talk, which ends with her rightly saying, public spaces are why we stay in a city.